Fahrenheit 9/11 review
Yesterday we went to see an afternoon showing of
this here in Washington Township. The theater was maybe one-third full,
a good deal less than the Harry Potter
movie that we saw recently. It was a different audience makeup, to
be sure, well-mannered and attentive particularly during the harrowing
interview of a Michigan woman who once would have been called a "Gold
Star mother" - it was as if everyone held their breath at that point,
the emotional center of the film.
The movie sometimes gave me the impression of a
feature-length short on the web, rather than a "real" film. It was the
cutting in of irreverent cultural clips along with grainy footage and
cheap little gags along the way. Perhaps this is the movie itself, or
maybe it is just the independent documentary style, or perhaps it's just
Michael Moore's way. The one point which left my face wet was
the short montage describing the events of September 11th as the horror
unfolded.
I know there's been a lot of criticism of the
facts as presented here, particularly of the first part of the film
which is heavy on the political conspiracy aspect of the current
administration's response to 9/11. The stronger part of the movie seems
to be the second half which takes up the advent of the Iraq war along
with interviews with those most directly affected by the war. I was
wondering during this part what it would have been like if it could have
included the revelations of prison abuse and the current spate of
hostage executions (it did include mention of the one early incident of
Japanese civilians who had been threatened with burning alive),
upping the stakes.
So how many Congressmen had enlisted sons during
even the most popular wars (say WWII)? That would have put the "only
one out of 535" figure for this war into context. And I didn't completely buy
the vague implication that there was some sort of benefit
accruing to the bin Laden family related to 9/11 - to me, it does not
seem so farfetched that two families high up in the same business
would have had extensive dealings over the years without anything
necessarily nefarious about it. Still, I think that if even a fraction
of the charges made here are unassailable that would make for a
pretty persuasive case against the Administration and its cronies
in big business.
I don't know whether this will affect the outcome
of the Fall election directly, because I kind of doubt that the truly
undecided voters in battleground states will be watching this sort of
movie. But I don't think it will drop out of the discussion for
many months to come whether it swings the outcome or not.